Question

Is the ICMA Code of Ethics too long? Governing.com thinks so.

  1  
Kevin Carter
Kevin Carter asked

From Govering.com,
"The International City/County Management Association has a pretty good code of ethics except that it's 2000 words long, has a 3200-word supplementary "Rules of Procedure for Enforcement," and is written by lawyers or at least by people who have mastered esoteric, lawyerly writing. Most people can't ...live by the ICMA code because they simply can't remember any of it."

As a member, do you live by the ICMA Code of Ethics? Do you find the 12 Tenets difficult to follow or remember (or if you’re not-in-service to local government, only Tenets 1 and 3)? Or are they inherent in the values of professional and good governance?

For the whole article:

http://www.governing.com/columns/mgmt-insights/A-Wallet-Sized-Code-of.html

Richard Brown

I don't think that the real issue is whether the ICMA Code of Ethics is too long or not. I think that the issue is what can we as managers do to to impart a culture of ethical behavior in our organizations. In some cases, especially when dealing with a diverse workforce, that means distilling the essence of ethical standards into a format that all can use.

It's my hope that these discussions not focus on whether the code is too long or whether an index sized code of ethics is appropriate. The more important discussion is how we can impart the importance of ethical behavior into our organizations and make it an essential part of our culture.

Margaret Mullendore-Cluckey

I find that the code is not too long and it’s not hard to follow; in all honesty I don’t think it to be legally confusing with its verbiage. For me, I lean towards the thought process that common sense tends to lead/rule the way. I live by the decree if I have to question something chances are I probably should steer clear. We need to be ardent in staying neutral on issues and activities because we are under much greater scrutiny and having a code of ethics that we ascribe to shows our dedication to doing the right thing; even when it is sometimes unpopular. I know managers that don't necessarily adhere to the twelve tenants but believe that when we made the decision to be public employees we also made the commitment to living by a higher standard in our professional and personal lives.

Please sign in to comment.

Answers

 
  2  
Martha Perego

Too bad that Bob Sloan, who is generally thoughtful about this issue, didn't do a bit more research before making his statement. The Code, written by members NOT LAWYERS, connects the mission to the job. Its the foundation that inspires and guides their conduct every day in a countless number of decisions they make. As educated committed professionals we can't subscribe to something that doesn't fit on the back of a card? I don't believe it but if you want to get it to the elevator speech here goes: "We commit to deliver fair, equitable and efficient services in a transparent way to the community we serve. We will respect and promote our Democracy and stay out of politics. We will seek no favor. We act with integrity in our personal and professional conduct to merit the trust of those we serve. We will treat out employees, elected officials and residents with respect. We are building communities that will outlast us." Is that too hard to remember?

 
  1  
Karen Pinkos

When I saw this item on the ICMA Twitter feed, I tweeted a pretty strong response to Governing.com that thousands of people follow the Code every day, and that we don't need a shortcut to be ethical. Governing.com then contacted me and invited me to respond to the column! I am glad to have had the opportunity to do so. Feel free to let me know what you think.

Link: http://www.governing.com/blogs/view/length-public-ethics-codes.html

 
  1  
Timothy Wolff

I think the code itself is fine. With that said, it is my opinion that the guidelines often go beyond what the actual code requires, and really should not be included in the same document as the code itself. I would rather see the guidelines, with examples of how it has been enforced as a different document updated annually showing the application of the code.

 
  0  
Michael Embury

Too long? With the myriad of issues managers face on a daily basis, a comprehensive code of ethics should be detailed and length has no bearing. The implication thaat length = inability to remember is an insult to the membership and our committment to the code.

 
  0  
Tanner Fortney

I believe the ICMA Code of Ethics is very well written and is not difficult to follow if you take the time to not only read but understand the ethical basis behind the code. Like anything else, if you do not use the code and apply it on a constant basis, you will forget the tenants. I think I can speak for others when I say I consciously consider the code on a daily basis and it is very important for all public servants in the decision-making process. I do not feel "shortening" the code will make it easier to follow, but rather will make it less useful.

 
  0  
Russell McAllister

The code of ethics is straightforward and serves as a pretty good compass to navigate governance issues. It seems to me that the goal is good governance and that is characterized by honesty, accountability, transparency, and inclusion. I have found myself working these last few years in environemnts characterized by an absence of ethics. It corrodes institutions, corrupts bureaucracies, deters investment, and undermines the legitimacy of government. Be thankful that you discuss the length of a code of ethics rather than suffer from and bemoan the absence of ethical behavior.

Your Answer

Please sign in to post your answer.

This Question

Asked
13 May 2010
Answers
6
Latest Activity
28 May 2010

Related Topics

Codes of Ethics Ethics